Bitcoin Firm Strategy (MSTR) at Risk of MSCI Index Removal

Strategy at risk of MSCI index removal

Strategy (MSTR) has become more likely to be dropped from MSCI's global indexes. On October 15, MSCI finalized a new standard to sift out companies that lean toward holding assets like an investment fund.

The final list of affected securities will be published on November 11, and the index change is scheduled to take effect after the close on November 30.

If MSTR is removed, funds that track the MSCI index exactly will have to sell their MSTR holdings, which are no longer in the index composition, to match weights.

That's not because fund managers dislike the company; it's mechanical selling that arises from keeping the same composition as the index. Either way, it's no light matter. It's forced selling at large scale.

✦ Strategy (MSTR) Closing Prices

Sep 23 to Oct 16, Nasdaq regular session (US Eastern Time)

$137$151$165MSCI news-9.56%Sep 23Oct 5Oct 16
Down about 15.6%, from $162.20 on Sep 23 to $136.83 on Oct 16.

The stock reacted sharply too. The announcement came after the US regular session closed on October 15, and on the next trading day, the 16th, MSTR closed at $136.83. That's a 9.56% drop from the day before.

Compared with its September 23 close of $162.20, it's down about 15.6%. The weakness that day wasn't limited to MSTR. As selling in tech stocks including AI companies intensified, the Nasdaq Composite also slid 2.1%, and the S&P 500 fell more than 1%.

Even so, MSTR's drop was 7.5 percentage points bigger than the Nasdaq's. With selling spreading across the whole market, it's natural to see it as MSTR also taking a stock-specific blow in the form of index removal.

What Is MSCI Trying to Change?

✦ MSCI New Standard Timeline

From the temporary measure to the index change

1Oct 10, 2025
Temporary measure for digital-asset-holding companies announced
2Aug 3, 2026
Consultation on non-operating company standard begins
3Oct 15, 2026
Final methodology adopted and announced
4Nov 11, 2026
Final list of affected securities expected
5Nov 30, 2026
Change applied after the US market close

This move doesn't mean "we'll kick out every company whose main business is crypto investing." In October 2025, MSCI announced a temporary measure freezing some index-inclusion changes for companies whose digital assets are half or more of total assets.

It started placing limits, such as on new additions to MSCI indexes or weight increases, for such companies.

This time, it's ending the earlier temporary measure and switching to a standard that looks at whether a company actually creates value through its operations rather than at how much of a particular asset it holds.

✦ How MSCI Screens

Two steps

✔ Core screen: Checks whether operating assets are sufficient
✔ If it falls short: Five financial ratios are weighed additionally
✔ Four or more: Ineligible signals mean ineligibility for index inclusion
✔ Existing constituents: Deletion candidate only after failing two annual reviews in a row

The new standard works in two steps. First, it checks whether a company has enough operating assets used in real business among its assets.

If it doesn't pass this review, it further weighs five financial ratios, including operating costs, operating cash flow, valuation changes in non-operating assets, and reliance on external financing.

If four or more of these meet the ineligibility criteria, a company can lose its eligibility for index inclusion. For stocks already included, though, it gives a little leeway.

A stock becomes a deletion candidate only if it fails the criteria in two annual reviews in a row, so not every targeted stock is thrown out right after the announcement.

The preliminary simulation MSCI released in August 2026 listed not only Strategy but also the UK uranium investment company Yellow Cake and the Japanese bitcoin-holding company Metaplanet as potential deletions.

Three companies, including SharpLink, were put on a watchlist. The final list of affected securities to be published on November 11 may differ, but it wouldn't be wrong to say they've effectively landed on a "hit list."

Why Does Strategy Fall Under This Standard?

Strategy does run a software business too. That was originally its main business. But as you know, not anymore. For this company, increasing its holdings through stock and bond issuance has effectively become the main business.

That can make it a target when MSCI reviews removal candidates. According to materials released on October 12, the company bought an additional 250 bitcoin for about $21.5 million from October 5 to 11, and its total holdings rose to 848,250.

Of the purchase funds, $21 million came from selling MSTR common stock, and the remaining $500,000 came from cash on hand. It's debatable, but it's understandable that people would say "Isn't it effectively an investment fund rather than a company?"

This single purchase shows the funding structure well. The company sells stock to raise cash and uses that money to buy more bitcoin.

If the stock is valued highly and can be issued on favorable terms, it helps increase bitcoin holdings, but if the share price premium shrinks or issuing new shares becomes hard, raising money the same way gets difficult.

Strategy's stock price is, in effect, influenced not only by the bitcoin price but also by whether the company can keep raising money in the capital markets.

✦ Both Sides Compared

MSCI and Strategy

MSCI
• Judges by asset structure and financial ratios
• Index eligibility rests on asset structure and financial indicators
Strategy
• A company running a bitcoin treasury strategy as operations
• Says it is not an investment fund
〈Saylor on MSCI, in his own words〉
* From the official Bloomberg Television channel.

Strategy has opposed MSCI's approach. It argues that it is not an 'investment fund' but a 'company that runs a real business,' and that its bitcoin treasury strategy is part of corporate operations.

MSCI, on the other hand, holds the position that however each company packages its business, it will judge index eligibility by asset structure and financial indicators from now on.

The $2.8 Billion Selling Story Is Not a Confirmed Number

✦ $2.8 Billion vs 3.1%

Different bases and denominators, so no direct comparison

JPMorgan scenario (2025)About $2.8 billion on MSCI removal; about $8.8 billion more if other major index providers follow
Potential outflow
Strategy's claimAbout 3.1% of outstanding common shares held by MSCI index-linked funds
Share of outstanding stock

The number that stirred controversy in this issue is '$2.8 billion.'

In November 2025, JPMorgan analysts estimated that if the proposal being discussed at the time to remove MSTR from MSCI indexes were carried out, about $2.8 billion of selling could come from funds tracking MSCI indexes.

They also raised the possibility of an additional outflow of about $8.8 billion if other major index providers followed.

This number is a scenario calculated from the situation and market size in 2025. It doesn't mean actual selling has been confirmed under this final rule.

Passive funds that track an index exactly have to dispose of their holdings if MSTR drops out of the constituents, but not every institutional investor makes the same choice.

Active funds can keep holding if they want, regardless of the index change, and other indexes like the Nasdaq-100 apply their own inclusion criteria. Still, it's a fair worry that a considerable amount of selling could come out.

For now, the Strategy side reassured investors by offering a different number.

According to the comments they submitted to MSCI, the MSTR common stock held by funds that track MSCI Global Investable Market Indexes is about 3.1% of all outstanding common shares.

Based on this share, they argued that the direct impact of index-linked selling is limited.

So What Should Investors Watch?

✦ The Investment Logic

What happens after removal

Index removal
MSTR leaves the index composition
Smaller holdings
Index-tracking funds reduce their holdings
Short-term flows
Short-term supply and demand shift
Longer-term effect
Impact on institutional valuation and funding conditions
〈A Fundstrat analyst on the MSCI exclusion〉
* From the official Bitcoin Magazine channel.

You should pay more attention to what happens after removal than to the selling on the day itself. Once it drops out of the index, the buying demand from passive funds that had to include MSTR disappears too.

Looking further out, how the market will evaluate Strategy going forward is the big variable. The market hasn't valued MSTR only by the value of the bitcoin it holds; it has also priced in the strategy of issuing stock and bonds to buy more bitcoin.

The part that this expectation added to the stock price was the valuation premium. JPMorgan analysts also saw in past analysis that removal from MSCI indexes could clearly weigh on such a premium, on liquidity, and on future funding.

If the premium shrinks and the terms for issuing stock or bonds worsen too, the bitcoin-buying strategy could face constraints.

✦ Bitcoin (BTC/USD) Closing Prices

Sep 27 to Oct 15, CoinGecko daily close (UTC)

$81,604$84,047$86,490Sep 27Oct 6Oct 15
From $84,449 on Sep 27 to $82,156 on Oct 15.

Bitcoin's price has been limping along for a while now, and MSTR has to keep raising funds somehow and hold on until bitcoin starts rising again.

But if it is removed from MSCI indexes and struggles to fund itself because of lost credibility, MSTR's stock may find it hard to follow the bitcoin price one-for-one.

Even if bitcoin rebounds, MSTR's gain could be small, and in a falling market the drop could be bigger in turn.

For now, the important dates are November 11, when the final list of affected securities under the new standard is published (being on it doesn't confirm removal), and the actual index change applied at the close of November 30.

If MSTR actually becomes a removal target, selling pressure from passive funds that track the index could occur. MSTR has now become a stock that's hard to judge by the bitcoin price alone.

It will come under doubt not only over the direction of bitcoin but over its ability to raise funds through stock issuance. Can Michael Saylor, the stylish guy, overcome this crisis?

This isn't investment advice. You know that, right? Let's each protect our own hard-earned money.

That's all for this post. See you next time.

Related posts

No comments:

No comments yet. Want to leave the first one?