Samsung Electronics at KRW 70,000, SK hynix at KRW 200,000. Compared with the October 16 close, these are prices Samsung Electronics would have to fall 67.5% and SK hynix 84.3% to reach.
For SK hynix, that means falling more than KRW 1 million from the current price. The person who put forward these fair prices is Joowan Lee, an industry analyst.
After stating the fair prices for both companies on SBS Biz on October 8, he repeated the same claim on YTN Radio on the 16th. The host even brought up that the video had become a magnet for people coming back to leave comments.
What kind of calculation could lead to the conclusion that one-third of today's price, or even one-sixth, is fair?
Where Did This Target Come From?
✦ Timeline of the Target Controversy
From the remark to the revisit
First, let's be clear about what this is. The starting point of this controversy isn't an official target price report published by a brokerage research center, but a fair-price opinion that analyst Joowan Lee stated himself on air. His argument is simple.
The recent earnings and share prices of chip companies lean heavily on the surge in memory prices rather than on long-term structural improvement, and if memory prices come back down, earnings and stock valuations could fall together.
Memory is an industry where profits can snowball when prices rise. Even if production facilities and shipment volumes barely change, selling each chip at a higher price raises revenue and profit at the same time.
Conversely, once supply catches up with demand and prices fall, even if the same factory makes similar volumes, what's left over can shrink quickly. In effect, Joowan Lee sees the current earnings boom as close to the peak of this price cycle.
✦ Claims About PBR
The same indicator gives different multiples depending on the denominator
On air, he argued that the price-to-book ratio (PBR) of both companies has risen from around 1x in the past to about 4 to 7x now, calling them overvalued. PBR is an indicator showing how many times book net assets a stock trades at.
This figure changes depending on which point in time's net assets are used as the denominator, and by FnGuide's 2026 estimates, PBR was tallied at 2.41x for Samsung Electronics and 3.17x for SK hynix.
How Far Is It from the Brokerage Outlook?
✦ Target Comparison
Joowan Lee vs the three-month brokerage tally
In a tally of brokerage target prices over the last three months, Samsung Electronics has an average of about KRW 495,000 across 22 institutions, with a range of KRW 270,000 to 650,000.
For SK hynix, the average across 22 institutions is about KRW 3.258 million, and the range stretches from a low of KRW 1.48 million to a high of KRW 4.7 million.
This aggregate compiled Samsung Electronics' targets as of October 15 and SK hynix's as of October 16.
The gap from the targets Joowan Lee put forward is huge, isn't it? His KRW 70,000 for Samsung Electronics is 85.9% below the average target and 74.1% below the lowest target in the tally, KRW 270,000.
His KRW 200,000 for SK hynix is 93.9% below the average, and 86.5% below even the lowest target of KRW 1.48 million.
The lows in the tally for both stocks are BNK Securities' forecasts, and the highs are KRW 650,000 and KRW 4.7 million from Korea Investment & Securities.
In particular, the highest-target reports came out in late July, so they don't reflect the recent plunge, but the fact that Joowan Lee's numbers sit far below even the tail end of ordinary bearish forecasts doesn't change.
Can Real Earnings Be Explained by a Bubble Alone?
✦ Both Companies' Earnings
Samsung Electronics Q3 preliminary, SK hynix Q2
Samsung Electronics announced preliminary third-quarter revenue of KRW 195 trillion and operating profit of KRW 107.4 trillion on October 8. Operating profit rose 782.5% from the same quarter a year earlier.
Just seeing a company post over KRW 100 trillion in operating profit in one quarter lets you feel how strongly memory prices pushed up corporate earnings. At the same time, it could also be risky to assume such record profits will simply continue.
After all, it's truly astonishing.
SK hynix's second-quarter results were just as hot. Revenue was KRW 79.3187 trillion and operating profit KRW 60.5426 trillion, with an operating margin of about 76%.
If I were running a business (and a manufacturing one, not a service business) and claimed a 76% operating margin, the people around me would think I was boasting. That's how impressive that margin is.
The company said it began volume shipments of HBM4 in the second quarter and pursued and signed multi-year supply contracts with about 10 major customers.
Considering not only rising memory prices but also growing sales of high-value products for AI servers and customers' moves to secure stable supply, I think it's hard to view the current profit entirely as a product of a temporary price spike.
The price outlook also points in a different direction from Joowan Lee's expectations.
He expected memory prices to turn downward from the fourth quarter, but market research firm TrendForce forecast in its September 30 report that fourth-quarter contract prices for commodity DRAM would rise 10 to 15% from the previous quarter, and NAND flash contract prices 15 to 20%.
TrendForce also noted that demand for consumer products is weak, but it expected AI server demand and supply shortages to keep pushing prices up.
Not every memory product moves in the same direction, but at least the major price forecasts published now stand on the opposite side of the expectation that 'memory prices break down from the fourth quarter.'
Does the Recent Plunge Prove His Claim?
✦ Samsung Electronics (005930) Closing Prices
Sep 29 to Oct 16, KRX regular session (KST)
✦ SK hynix (000660) Closing Prices
Sep 29 to Oct 16, KRX regular session (KST)
On October 15, Samsung Electronics plunged 9.48% and SK hynix 11.06%. The KOSPI also fell 7.57%, hitting a six-month low, and during the session the drop widened enough to trigger a circuit breaker that halted trading for 20 minutes.
Reuters reported that US inflation data, interest rate worries, and doubts about the sustainability of AI investment weighed on the selloff in Asian tech stocks.
✦ Samsung Electronics vs SK hynix
Sep 29 close = 100 (KRX regular session)
Compared with the September 29 close, on October 16 Samsung Electronics ended 20.9% lower and SK hynix 27.9% lower. It's clear that the short-term drop was quite large.
Honestly, until now Joowan Lee's opinion probably got no attention at all and was likely treated as a joke. But in the recent KOSPI crash, his target price suddenly started drawing the attention of investors worrying "Could it be???" "Surely not???"
It's also worth noting that Joowan Lee isn't someone who has always put out only pessimistic forecasts.
According to Weekly Kyunghyang's summary of his past remarks, he was positive on the SK hynix outlook in 2024, and in September 2025 he even said the stock price at the time was cheap relative to earnings.
His current pessimism starts from the judgment that memory prices have passed their peak. He isn't putting out absurd claims to bait attention or become a flash-in-the-pan star; he's making his case based on his own convictions.
Here's What I Think
The targets of Samsung Electronics at KRW 70,000 and SK hynix at KRW 200,000 are a bearish scenario in which negative conditions, such as falling memory prices and falling profit margins, occur all at once.
Judging by the data currently available, Samsung Electronics posted record preliminary third-quarter profit, and SK hynix is ramping up HBM4 volume production and multi-year supply contracts.
TrendForce's latest quarterly outlook also expects commodity DRAM and NAND contract prices to rise. Going by the facts we can confirm right now at least, there's not enough basis to accept these two numbers as the base-case scenario.
Still, they're enough to stir a "Could it be???" feeling amid the recent KOSPI selloff.
It isn't easy for an analyst to issue a negative outlook or a sell rating, and since he keeps sticking to a claim that prices will fall enormously from the current level, you can't help wondering, "Is there really something to it?"
This isn't investment advice. You know that, right? Let's each protect our own hard-earned money.
That's all for this post. See you next time.
Related posts
- KOSPI Plunges 7.57% on Oct 15: What Happened in Korea?
- Samsung & SK hynix Fall Together Despite the HBM Boom
- Broadcom CEO Likens Some AI Investors to Casino Gamblers
🌐 Korean version: 삼성전자 7만원, SK하이닉스 20만원...?? 충격적인 목표가의 정체는?
🌐 Japanese version: サムスン(Samsung)7万ウォン、ハイニックス20万ウォン?目標株価の正体
No comments:
No comments yet. Want to leave the first one?
Post a Comment