Michael Saylor: "This dip could use a little orange. Hmm♡"
On November 15, Michael Saylor, Strategy's chairman, posted another one of his familiar charts on X. It's the graph with orange dots marking every time he bought bitcoin, and this time he added a short line: "This dip could use a little orange."
Whenever Saylor posts something like this on a Sunday, news of an actual bitcoin purchase often follows before United States markets open on Monday, so the market's eyes snapped to it right away.
✦ Strategy's Bitcoin Holdings
As of November 8; the unrealized loss is based on the chart Saylor shared
Bitcoin slid to an intraday low of $62,081 in this downturn and is now bouncing around the $65,500 mark. Strategy's holdings have moved into deep loss territory too.
As of November 8, Strategy holds 850,364 bitcoin, about 4.05% of bitcoin's maximum supply, with a cumulative purchase cost of $64.16 billion and an average price of $75,456 per coin.
Based on the chart Saylor shared, the bitcoin is worth about $55.7 billion. So Strategy is sitting on an unrealized loss of about $8.46 billion right now.
That's a loss of more than 13% of the purchase cost, and every $1,000 move in bitcoin shifts the value by $850 million.
Hey Saylor... didn't you say you were buying more last time too? Did you actually buy?
✦ Where the $283.8 Million From Common Stock Sales Went
Nov 2-8, allocation ratio
Saylor shouted "Buying more on the dip!" But look at where Strategy's money has actually been going lately. Some of it looks a little fishy.
From November 2 to 8, Strategy sold about 2,051,348 shares of MSTR common stock on the market and raised $283.8 million.
But 66.3% of that money, $188.3 million, didn't go to bitcoin; it went to buying back and retiring about 1,887,464 shares of its own preferred stock (STRC), which pays a 12% variable rate a year.
The money spent on 1,036 bitcoin was $81.9 million, or 28.9%, and the remaining $13.6 million (4.8%) was stashed as cash.
Widen the window to early October through November 8 and the center of gravity is the same. In that period the company spent $1.0606 billion buying STRC preferred stock, about 4.8 times the $219.7 million it spent on bitcoin over the same stretch.
On the other hand, the money raised by issuing new preferred stock from November 2 to 8 was $0.
Unlike the old image of 'sell common stock, stack bitcoin forever,' what's really happening is that it has to use common stock proceeds to buy back high-rate preferred and protect its capital structure.
✦ Book Profit vs. Actual Cash
This year's Q3; cash flow is January-September
| Q3 total revenue | $125.43 million |
| Q3 net income | $19.53 billion |
| Operating profit or loss excluding fair-value gains | about $2.6 million loss |
| Jan-Sep operating cash flow | $14.3 million positive |
| Q3 preferred dividends | $419.1 million paid in cash |
The gap between book profit and actual cash flow is stark too. In Q3 this year, Strategy reported operating income of $20.91 billion and net income of $19.53 billion, which are enormous numbers.
But those numbers come from fair-value gains of $20.91239 billion booked as bitcoin's price rose. Revenue that quarter was $125.43 million, and without those gains Strategy posted a consolidated operating loss of about $2.6 million.
Cash is even tighter. Operating cash flow for January through September came to only $14.3 million, while $419.1 million went out in cash for preferred dividends in Q3 alone.
One quarter's dividends come to about 29 times the cash operations brought in over nine months...
The company has also turned some of its bitcoin into cash this year. In Q3 it bought 7,218 bitcoin while selling 5,552 ($348.56 million), so the net increase was just 1,666.
Total sales since the start of the year came to about $431.8 million as of October 25, and the board has even opened up authority for up to $1.25 billion in additional sales to bolster its dollar reserve.
Shockwaves From the MSCI Index Removal
✦ MSCI Removal Timeline and Scope
| November 11 | Removal confirmed in MSCI's regular review |
| November 30 | Removal takes effect right after the regular session closes |
| Indexes dropped from | MSCI USA · MSCI World · MSCI ACWI |
| 24 removed from MSCI USA | 23 moved to the small-cap index; only Strategy removed entirely |
With cash already tight, a major piece of bad news was confirmed on November 11. MSCI, the global benchmark index provider, decided in its regular review to remove Strategy from all of the MSCI USA, MSCI World and MSCI ACWI indexes.
The removal itself takes effect right after the regular session closes on November 30.
MSCI applied a new 'non-operating company' standard it finalized this year. About 99% of Strategy's total assets are bitcoin-related.
As a result, it failed four or more of the five financial ratio tests, covering things like operating expenses, operating cash flow and reliance on outside financing, and got classified as an investment-fund-like entity rather than an ordinary operating company.
That's why, of the 24 stocks dropped from MSCI USA this time, 23 just got moved down to a small-cap index, but only Strategy got dropped from MSCI USA completely.
Opinions are split on how much passive money will need to go right away.
Downward pressure on the stock does get stronger when passive fund money flows out, but Strategy's side pushes back, saying MSCI-linked fund volume is limited and the market can absorb it easily.
✦ Strategy vs. Spot Bitcoin ETF, Last 21 Trading Days
MSTR and IBIT regular-session closes, October 16, 2026 = 100
Either way, I doubt you can treat the MSCI removal as just a 'one-day mechanical selling event'.
Over the last 21 trading days (October 16 to November 13), the spot bitcoin ETF (IBIT) fell 15.62% while Strategy fell 18.42%, closing at $111.62 on November 13.
Since the short-term peak on October 21, IBIT (the spot bitcoin ETF) dropped 18.60% while Strategy plunged a full 27.27%. On November 12, right after the index removal was confirmed, it fell 6.49% in a single day.
If you're an investor, it's probably frustrating to wonder why Strategy's stock has been so weak lately.
✦ Growth in Share Count vs. Bitcoin Count
So far this year
Sure, Strategy keeps growing its bitcoin stack, but there's something a little fishy here, too.
Basic shares outstanding are up 36.4% this year, from 312.06 million to 425.59 million, while total bitcoin holdings only grew 26.4%, from 672,500 to 850,364.
So 'BTC Yield,' which shows how much the amount of bitcoin behind each share changed over the period, has slipped too: down 3.7% year to date (down 11.9% in Q3 alone).
In other words, the shares being issued to buy bitcoin are growing faster than the bitcoin itself.
Saylor: "Heh heh, don't worry. The money will keep coming in. Hmm♡"
Strategy said it plans to raise money by issuing perpetual preferred stock that pays dividends in the 8-12% range a year.
Saylor also explained that, with its current financial structure, it has the potential to issue $10 billion to $30 billion of preferred stock.
On top of that, it's boosting demand for preferred by applying a bold twist to its core preferred, STRC: dividends that accrue daily.
Back in the bitcoin bull markets, Saylor didn't need to explain much of anything. After all, as long as bitcoin kept rising, the structure could produce enormous profits.
But now it's the unrealized losses that have piled up, and Saylor keeps rolling out 'digital credit' and 'perpetual preferred' and one thing after another in an effort to reassure investors.
It's hard to value Strategy with traditional metrics like P/E.
Trailing 12-month earnings per share are a loss of $60.88, so you can't even calculate a P/E, and opinions are split on whether the bitcoin Strategy holds as its core asset can be valued the same way with traditional metrics like price-to-book.
For what it's worth, analysts calculate a forward P/E of 3.75x using the November 13 close ($111.62) and expected earnings per share over the next 12 months ($29.73). Looking at that number alone, it looks like a wildly undervalued company.
But that's the result of plugging in a huge fair-value gain estimate that assumes bitcoin's price rebounds.
✦ Strategy Analyst Price Target Consensus
17 firms tracked by MarketBeat; baseline is the November 13 close (Nasdaq regular session)
Ratings are 2 Strong Buy, 12 Buy, 2 Hold and 1 Sell.
So what does Wall Street think? Of the 17 firms with ratings and price targets tracked by MarketBeat, 2 rate it Strong Buy, 12 Buy, 2 Hold and 1 Sell, for a consensus of 'Moderate Buy.'
Compared with the November 13 close of $111.62, the price targets are $165.00 at the low (+47.82%), $244.79 on average (+119.31%) and $435.00 at the high (+289.72%), and even the most conservative figure is about 48% above the current price.
(Wall Street targets tend to run generous anyway, so take them with a grain of salt)
November 30 and 2027: Three Hurdles Strategy Has to Clear
✦ Three Hurdles Strategy Has to Clear
Three turning points will decide Strategy's stock price and its capacity to keep buying bitcoin.
First up is checking how hard the hit is on November 30, the day the MSCI removal takes effect.
If the market comfortably absorbs the passive selling concentrated in the closing auction of the regular session, the index removal could end up as just a short-term supply-and-demand event.
On the flip side, if the selling pressure turns heavy and the stock falls sharply, Strategy's financing flexibility drops a lot too.
Second is the annual interest and dividend burden, and whether preferred issuance resumes. Right now Strategy carries $6.714 billion in convertible bonds, which are bonds that can be swapped for stock, and about $12.946 billion in perpetual preferred stock.
So it has to pay about $1.461 billion a year in interest and dividends.
It has lined up a buffer of about $4.9162 billion, roughly 3.4 years' worth, counting its dividend reserve and general cash, but if it can't keep drawing steady investor demand for preferred stock, investors' anxiety will grow.
Third is the pressure from convertible bond redemptions and when bitcoin gets back above its average purchase price ($75,456).
The conversion prices on the bonds it has issued are all set above the current stock price, from a low of $149.77 to a high of $672.40, so bondholders have much less incentive to convert to stock.
If bitcoin climbs back above $75,456 and the stock rebounds, this structure will regain strength.
But if the stock stays weak for long, keep in mind that real cash repayment pressure could start in earnest from September 15, 2027, the first date bondholders can exercise the put right to demand their principal back (the 2028 notes, $1.01 billion).
This isn't investment advice. You know that, right? Let's each protect our own hard-earned money.
That's all for this post. See you next time.
Related posts
- Saylor's $100K Bitcoin Call: What It Means for Strategy
- Bitcoin Firm Strategy (MSTR) at Risk of MSCI Index Removal
- MARA Sold $1.1 Billion of Bitcoin as BTC Fell Below $68,000
🌐 Korean version: MSCI에서 쫓겨난 스트래티지(MSTR), 84억 달러 평가손실에도 "비트코인 추가매수!" 외쳤다?
🌐 Japanese version: MSCI除外のストラテジー、含み損84億ドルで「BTC買い増し!」?
No comments:
No comments yet. Want to leave the first one?
Post a Comment